Settlement agreements UK: when to use them and how to handle the process properly

Sometimes, an employment relationship reaches a point where carrying on as you are no longer feels right for the business or the person involved. Knowing what to do next is not always straightforward.

Perhaps you have been working through performance concerns for some time, a grievance has affected working relationships, or a restructure means a role is changing. Sometimes, both sides recognise that an agreed departure may be a better way forward than continuing with something that is not working.

It can be a sensitive conversation to navigate. You may be wondering whether a settlement agreement is the right option, or worrying about how to raise it without making a difficult situation harder.

For us, the starting point is understanding what has happened and what a fair, practical way forward could look like for everyone involved.

A settlement agreement is a legally binding, voluntary agreement between an employer and a worker, former worker or, in some circumstances, a job applicant. It can settle an employment dispute, end an employment relationship on agreed terms, or sometimes resolve an issue while employment continues. A valid agreement can include an agreed payment, reference wording, confidentiality terms and an agreement not to pursue the specific legal claims listed in it.

But the document itself is rarely the difficult bit.

The difficult bit is deciding when to use a settlement agreement, how to start that conversation, what a reasonable deal looks like and what happens if the person says no.

That is where the judgement sits.

What is a settlement agreement in the UK?

Put simply, a settlement agreement is a written legal contract that allows an employer and an individual to resolve specific employment claims or disputes on terms they both agree to.

You may remember them as compromise agreements. The name has changed, but the idea is the same: agreeing how to bring particular issues to a close, with clarity for both sides about what has been settled.

There are some important legal requirements to get right. As the Acas Code of Practice on Settlement Agreements explains, the agreement must be in writing and relate to a particular complaint or proceedings. The individual must receive advice from a relevant independent adviser about what the agreement means, including how it affects their ability to pursue the claims it covers. The adviser must have appropriate insurance and be named in the agreement. The agreement must also confirm that the statutory requirements regulating settlement agreements have been met.

 

The key is being clear about exactly what both sides are agreeing to settle.

It is not enough simply to say the agreement is in “full and final settlement of all claims”. The claims being settled need to be properly identified, so the wording needs careful attention.

That is why we would always start with the situation in front of you, rather than simply reusing the agreement from the last person who left. Getting the paperwork right matters, but so does the people process around it. That same focus on clear documentation and consistent processes runs through our HR Policy + Process Consultancy.

 

For us, that means taking time to understand the circumstances, the claims that need to be considered and how the conversations are handled, well before anyone is ready to sign.

When should an employer use a settlement agreement?

When you are working through a difficult employment situation, it is understandable to wonder whether a settlement agreement could help.

For us, the starting point is to take a step back together.

Rather than simply asking whether settlement is an option, we would look at whether it is the right approach for the business and the person involved.

As Acas explains, settlement agreements are one of several ways to approach these situations. Depending on what has happened, a performance, disciplinary or grievance process, or an honest conversation, may be more appropriate.

That can be harder to weigh up when a situation has been going on for months and everyone is feeling the strain. Taking a little time to work through the options can help bring things back into focus.

A settlement agreement may be helpful where an agreed outcome offers both sides more certainty than continuing a formal process. It can also provide a way to resolve a genuine dispute before it takes up more time, energy and legal costs.

The important thing is that it sits alongside thoughtful people management, rather than taking its place.

If someone has not had clear feedback about their performance, for example, a settlement proposal could come as a real surprise. Before starting that conversation, we would want to understand what has been discussed, what support has been offered and whether the person has had a fair opportunity to respond to the concerns.

Settlement may still be part of the way forward. It is simply important to recognise that an agreement does not, on its own, put right any gaps in the process that came before it.

When an agreed exit may be better than another process

Imagine someone who has played an important part in a growing business, but whose senior role now looks quite different from the one they originally took on.

When the team had 20 people, their approach worked really well. Now there are 80, and the role calls for different leadership, delegation and commercial responsibilities. There have been open conversations, clear expectations and support, but both sides recognise that things are still not working as they had hoped.

A formal capability process may be the next step. Equally, there may be a point where both sides would welcome a conversation about an agreed departure.

In this example, settlement is not a way to sidestep a difficult conversation. Those conversations have already taken place, and an agreed exit is being considered as one possible way forward.

For us, that is an important distinction.

Before suggesting settlement, we would want to understand whether there are conversations or management steps that still need attention, and whether the alternatives have been properly explored. The aim is to choose a route thoughtfully, rather than simply find the quickest way through a difficult situation.

Acas encourages employers to look at the wider picture: the cost of the proposed payment, whether settlement is the best way to resolve the issue, what happens to the employment relationship if no agreement is reached, and the possible effect on the wider team.

So the decision is about more than the potential cost of a tribunal. It is about finding a fair, practical way forward, with care for the people involved and the business as a whole.

How does the settlement agreement process work?

The process starts well before anyone puts an agreement on the table. Taking time to prepare can make a sensitive conversation easier to approach.

We would begin by understanding what has happened, the legal and people issues that need careful thought, and the other options available. It is also worth being clear about what you hope to achieve, so the proposal has a considered purpose behind it.

With that preparation in place, the next step is a conversation.

Acas recommends that the employer and worker meet to discuss the proposal. This is a chance to explain why you are suggesting settlement and give the person space to ask questions. Be clear that it is voluntary: they can negotiate, make a counter-offer or decide not to accept. Declining the proposal should not affect the fairness of any separate performance or disciplinary process.

That separation matters, both in what you say and in what happens next.

If the person says no, that should not be treated as a decision to dismiss them. Any separate process still needs to be handled fairly, without assuming the outcome in advance.

We know it can feel difficult to keep those conversations separate when they involve the same people and circumstances. Our Employee Relations Services can help you work through the settlement discussion alongside any capability, disciplinary, grievance or redundancy process, keeping each route clear and carefully managed.

A practical settlement agreement employer guide

Before you open the conversation, we would work through six questions with you: why are you considering settlement; what would the alternative process look like; which potential claims need assessing; what financial and non-financial terms could you reasonably offer; who is best placed to lead the conversation; and what will happen if you cannot reach an agreement?

Working through those questions can help you feel clearer and more prepared. If you would value ongoing support rather than help with a single situation, our Retained HR Team works alongside leaders and managers as things develop.

 

It is natural for someone to ask, “Why are you suggesting this?” Having a clear, thoughtful answer helps them understand the proposal and reduces the risk of confusion or mistrust.

For the manager leading the conversation, being able to explain the situation, the proposed approach and the alternatives calmly can make it feel more manageable too.

You do not need to script every word. The aim is to feel prepared enough to listen, respond with care and be clear about what happens next.

How should settlement agreement negotiations be handled?

It helps to approach settlement discussions as a conversation, with room for both sides to put forward what matters to them.

Your first proposal is a starting point, rather than something the other person has to accept as it stands.

Acas recognises that either side can make proposals and counter-proposals until they find terms they can agree on, or decide that agreement is not possible.

The payment will naturally be an important part of that conversation, but it is worth looking beyond the figure too.

You may also need to discuss the leaving date, notice, holiday, bonus arrangements, benefits, reference and announcement wording, confidentiality, restrictive covenants, return of company property and legal costs.

With so much attention on the payment, it can be easy to overlook how much the other terms mean to each side.

For the person leaving, an agreed reference may offer real reassurance about their next step. For the business, a workable departure date can allow time for a handover. Agreeing what colleagues and clients will be told can also ease uncertainty for everyone involved.

Understanding those priorities can help both sides find common ground, rather than assuming that a higher payment is the only way forward.

How long should someone have to consider a settlement agreement?

Giving someone time to think and take advice is an important part of handling the discussion with care.

The Acas Code says a reasonable period depends on the circumstances. As a general rule, the person should have at least 10 calendar days to consider the formal written terms and obtain independent advice, unless both sides agree otherwise.

Think of that as guidance on allowing enough time, not a rule that every agreement must be signed within exactly 10 days.

Some people may need longer, including where reasonable adjustments are needed. Acas gives the example of a disabled employee who needs a sign-language interpreter to obtain advice.

We would also be mindful of how any deadline is communicated.

A deadline of tomorrow or lunchtime can leave someone feeling rushed. Linking acceptance to a threat, such as “Sign this or we start disciplinary action”, can also put pressure on the conversation.

You can be clear about the likely alternatives if agreement is not reached. The important distinction is between explaining those alternatives calmly and using them to pressure someone into signing.

Are settlement agreement conversations confidential?

Confidentiality can feel reassuring, but it is worth understanding exactly what protection applies before you start the conversation.

You may have heard settlement discussions described as “without prejudice” or “off the record”. It is easy to read those phrases as meaning that nothing said can ever be referred to again.

In practice, the protection depends on the circumstances and the type of claim.

Two different protections may be relevant: the common-law without prejudice principle and section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996.

Without prejudice protection normally requires an existing dispute and a genuine attempt to settle it. Section 111A can protect certain pre-termination discussions even without an existing dispute, but that statutory protection applies to ordinary unfair dismissal claims and has important limits.

Before asking a manager to have an “off-the-record chat”, we would help them understand what that means in the particular situation.

The wording you use matters, but it is no substitute for a carefully handled conversation.

Case study: Faithorn Farrell Timms LLP v Bailey

The Employment Appeal Tribunal decision in Faithorn Farrell Timms LLP v Bailey [2016] IRLR 839 helps illustrate why those distinctions matter.

The case concerned settlement discussions alongside claims including constructive unfair dismissal and indirect sex discrimination. The EAT considered how section 111A worked alongside the without prejudice principle, and which material could be used as evidence.

The EAT confirmed that section 111A protection is tied to ordinary unfair dismissal proceedings: it does not make settlement discussions confidential for every type of employment claim. It also examined improper behaviour, making clear that section 111A must be considered under its own statutory rules, rather than treated as another name for without prejudice privilege.

For employers, the useful takeaway is to prepare rather than assume.

Before the meeting, take advice on whether the discussion could be referred to in any relevant proceedings.

Being clear about the protection you are relying on, and its limits, puts you in a better position to approach the conversation thoughtfully.

What counts as improper behaviour during settlement negotiations?

Acas identifies bullying, harassment, intimidation, victimisation, discrimination, physical threats and other criminal behaviour as examples of conduct that may amount to improper behaviour.

Undue pressure can count too. That includes not allowing reasonable time to consider an offer, or telling someone before a disciplinary process has taken place that they will be dismissed if they turn the proposal down.

You can still have a clear and honest conversation about the situation.

Explain why settlement is being proposed and describe the possible alternatives factually. If there is a genuine disciplinary issue, for example, that may mean explaining that disciplinary proceedings could continue if agreement is not reached.

The key is to keep an open mind about any separate process, rather than presenting an undecided outcome as a foregone conclusion.

Case study: Tarbuc v Martello Piling Ltd [2026] EAT 58

In Mr L Tarbuc v Martello Piling Ltd [2026] EAT 58, Judge Stout handed down the Employment Appeal Tribunal’s decision on 28 April 2026.

Before Mr Tarbuc’s employment ended, purportedly by reason of redundancy, his employer held a conversation intended to be a protected pre-termination negotiation under section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996. The Employment Tribunal treated the conversation as inadmissible and rejected his argument that the employer had behaved improperly.

The EAT found that the conversation should not have been excluded from his unlawful deduction from wages and part-time worker claims, because section 111A protection is limited to ordinary unfair dismissal proceedings. It also found that the Tribunal had looked too narrowly at possible improper behaviour. Rather than focusing only on the manager’s words and manner, it needed to consider the circumstances as a whole, including Mr Tarbuc’s complaints that the meeting was unexpected and that he had not had the opportunity to bring a companion.

The judgment also considers the Acas Code. Its examples do not prevent an employer from explaining neutrally why settlement is being proposed or setting out the likely alternatives factually, including a disciplinary process where that is genuinely relevant.

In practical terms, “If we cannot agree terms, the performance process will continue” explains a next step. “If you do not sign this, we will dismiss you” may suggest that the decision has already been made. Keeping that distinction clear helps you explain the options without putting pressure on the person.

What happens if the employee rejects the settlement agreement?

It helps to think this through before making an offer, so you are prepared whichever way the conversation goes.

Settlement is voluntary. The person may not want to enter into an agreement, or may not be comfortable with the terms you have proposed.

Having a clear alternative gives you a considered next step if you cannot agree.

Depending on the situation, that could mean continuing a capability process, carrying on with an investigation or disciplinary process, handling a grievance properly, or following the appropriate consultation in a genuine redundancy situation.

Whatever the route, it needs to be fair and capable of standing on its own, independently of the settlement discussion.

If you are unsure what would happen without an agreement, it is worth taking time to work that through before raising the proposal.

There is a wider team perspective to consider as well.

Colleagues may never know the terms of an agreement, but the way someone leaves can still shape how they feel about the business.

If settlement becomes the usual response to difficult situations, managers may miss opportunities to build confidence in handling those conversations themselves.

Supporting managers to develop those skills remains important, whatever happens in an individual case.

How much should an employer offer in a settlement agreement?

There is no single figure that will be right for every settlement agreement. The starting point is the situation you are trying to resolve.

You will need to consider the potential claims, length of service, salary and contractual entitlements, alongside the likely time and cost of another process. The strength of each side’s position and the value they place on certainty can also shape the discussion.

The person’s own circumstances matter too. What feels workable for them may not be captured by the business’s legal assessment alone.

That is why we would look at each case on its own facts, rather than use the last settlement payment as a ready-made answer.

It also helps to be clear about what each part of the package is for, separating contractual payments from the genuine termination element.

HMRC’s guidance explains that unpaid wages, holiday pay, bonuses and payment in lieu of notice are generally subject to tax and National Insurance in the usual way. Certain qualifying termination payments can benefit from the £30,000 Income Tax threshold, but post-employment notice pay does not fall within it. Employer Class 1A National Insurance can also apply to qualifying termination payments above £30,000.

So it is worth being careful with phrases such as “the first £30,000 is tax free”. The tax treatment depends on what the payment represents, not simply the total amount of the package.

Do settlement agreements need an agreed reference?

Not necessarily. Signing a settlement agreement does not, in itself, generally mean an employer has to provide a reference.

A reference can, however, be negotiated as part of the agreement. Acas says that where wording is agreed, the employer should use it when providing the agreed written or verbal reference.

We would bring this into the conversation early, rather than leave it as a final detail.

For someone moving on after several years, knowing what their employer will say about them can offer reassurance at an uncertain time. It may matter just as much to them as some of the financial terms.

Agreeing the wording while you are discussing the other terms can also help avoid misunderstandings later.

Should settlement agreements include confidentiality clauses?

They can have a place, but it is worth asking whether one is needed in the particular circumstances.

Acas says confidentiality clauses in settlement agreements are voluntary. Its template guidance says they should be used where necessary, rather than included automatically in every agreement.

We would start with the purpose, rather than the standard wording.

What needs to remain confidential: the amount, the terms, commercial information or the circumstances of the departure? Being clear about that helps you focus the drafting on what is actually needed.

The limits matter too. A confidentiality clause should not prevent lawful whistleblowing or reporting a crime. Acas’s template guidance also says the wording should not try to discourage someone from raising concerns about wrongdoing or unlawful conduct.

There is a wider question to keep in mind as well.

If confidentiality clauses are being used regularly, it is worth taking a step back to understand why.

Acas recommends monitoring the use of non-disclosure agreements, as repeated use may point to issues within the organisation that need attention, rather than simply being contained.

We would take the same thoughtful approach to settlement agreements more broadly.

Alongside checking that each agreement has been handled properly, ask whether there is anything the business could learn from the pattern. That may be an opportunity to improve the experience for everyone.

How JourneyHR can help

If you are considering a settlement agreement, you do not have to work through the people questions on your own. We support founders and leadership teams with the thinking and conversations around the agreement, not just the paperwork at the end.

That might mean talking through whether settlement is the right option, understanding what has happened so far, or preparing the manager who will lead the conversation. We can also help you keep the discussion separate from any capability, disciplinary, grievance or redundancy process, and plan what happens if agreement is not reached.

Independent legal advice is important where the potential claims, tax position, contractual terms or proposed agreement need specialist attention. The employee must also receive advice from an appropriate independent adviser for the agreement to meet the statutory requirements.

Our role is to help you approach the people process with clarity and care, alongside the legal advice needed.

An agreement may help bring a difficult situation to a close. Taking care with the process around it matters just as much.

Talk to JourneyHR about a settlement agreement

Whether you are exploring an agreed exit or are unsure how to approach the next conversation, we would be happy to talk it through with you.

Get in touch with JourneyHR

Final thought

A settlement agreement can offer another way forward when continuing the employment relationship, or the dispute, no longer feels like the best outcome for both sides.

The value lies in choosing that route with care, rather than feeling you have run out of ways to handle a difficult situation.

Before you start the conversation, take time to be clear about why you are proposing settlement, what a fair agreement might look like and what happens if the person says no.

If that last question still feels difficult to answer, that is a useful place to pause and get support. You do not need to have every answer straight away, but it helps to work through the options before opening the discussion.

FAQs

What is a settlement agreement in the UK?

Put simply, it is a voluntary, legally binding written agreement to resolve specific employment claims or disputes. It can also set out agreed terms for ending employment. To validly waive the relevant claims, it must meet statutory conditions, including independent advice for the individual and proper identification of the claims being settled.

When should an employer use a settlement agreement?

It may be worth considering where an agreed outcome offers both sides more certainty than continuing a dispute or employment process. The starting point is to understand the circumstances, legal risks, relationship, costs and realistic alternatives if agreement is not reached. Settlement should not automatically take the place of performance management, disciplinary action, grievance handling or redundancy consultation.

How long should an employee have to consider a settlement agreement?

The Acas Code recommends at least 10 calendar days to consider the formal written terms and receive independent advice, unless both sides agree otherwise. What is reasonable depends on the circumstances, and some people may need longer, including where a reasonable adjustment is required. The aim is to give the person enough time to make an informed decision.

Can an employee negotiate a settlement agreement?

Yes. The first proposal is a starting point, and neither side has to accept it as it stands. Both can make proposals and counter-proposals about the payment and other terms, including notice, leaving date, references, confidentiality and benefits. The agreement remains voluntary throughout.

What happens if an employee refuses a settlement agreement?

If the person says no, the agreement does not go ahead unless further discussions lead to terms both sides accept. The employer then needs to consider the appropriate next steps, which might involve a capability, disciplinary, grievance or redundancy process. Any separate process must remain fair: declining settlement should not decide its outcome.

Next
Next

Job Description Template UK: How to Write a Role That Reflects the Work